Okay, you're talking about one of the most critically acclaimed games in recent years. And the ending you're describing is only to Halo 2. We're talking about Halo 3. Not the imperfections of the past games, where there was few. I bet it's only overrated to you because you've never played it. I'm just guessing, but you are the guy who told me to get a PS3 when my Xbox 360 fried.......