At GTW, we're starting a new project. This is a whole load of of gaming wikis joining together to make a new independent network.
We're making a wiki about games, and having an article for every game, including basic information but also having reviews.
Now, instead of 1 person giving the game an arbitrary score out of 10 for the wrong reasons, we're letting the whole community give their opinion, and essentially producing a set of justified recommendations based on that.
For a simple example: "FPS fans will love this game because it gets straight to the action, but those who prefer deep storylines and side-quests probably won't feel very satisfied. This is a game you can just pick up and play, without having to spend months building up your character, great for casual gamers but the MMORPG player might find it a bit simplistic."
What do you guys think of that?