If we do it like that, how many people would become Elite each month? Honestly, I like the voting idea and all, but the main thing that makes me not want to do it this way( and is a big reason why I like having the staff do it )is the fact that hey, maybe there isn't any people at the time being worthy of becoming Elite. Now would we just still do the voting and then welcome some noob to the Elite, or would we postpone the next voting? Either way, if there was an instance like this, it would be easier if it were just the staff voting like we already do.
And to keep the v.i.p.ish feeling of the Elite vital, wouldn't having people get picked each month be a little too much? Maybe we could lesson it to every 8 months( preferably longer ), and if you lose you still can be picked for the next one, because if we pick every 8 or so months, it'd seem silly to make someone who didn't win last time not get to be picked this time and have to wait 16 months to just get voted.
For the most part I like the idea, but I still prefer how we choose the Elite atm.