Who would win in a shootout?

[ThePunisher]

I think tommy would win in a shootout.

[TOXIC]

"please don't tell me that this is stupidity"

I think no one because both cities are far away LMFAO...j/k

I vote for Tommy

[TG187]

I don't know what was the idea of creating this topic. I will say me 2 times. If I will be CJ, I will kill Tommy and otherwise.

[draftermatt]

It would be CJ, as his aiming device worked so much better than Tommy's.

But really, there's no way to answer this as we never saw them "drawing" and guns fire pretty fast.

[Huckleberry Pie]

I dunno; both of them are great at shooting, so I had a hard time picking the winner...

[surrealistic ArtSweet]

this is a pointless, endless topic

from my opinion, i think CJ would win because his shooting skills, and there's more guns in SA than in VC & LC(except if you reffer it to GTA IV LC also)

Edited September 16, 2007 by ArtSweet

[Thomas.]

Both of them are me so Whats the point it would end up as a Draw. CJ would shoot Vercetti the same time as Vercetti would Shoot CJ because I clicked a Button. We would not know what it would be like if they were not Protagonists because they have only appeared in one GTA Game each.

[Scott.]

Oh its gotta be Vercetti.

[deathfun]

I would say CJ because he can have more health.

[Hooper]

CJ coz he is from the hood.

[weirdalfan27]

Although Tommy was my favorite main charecter tto date, I'd have to say CJ, because of his experience with more weapons, and has great skills for them.

[tilly]

CJ because he can hold guns. double minigun?

[Spaz The Great]

CJ because he can hold guns. double minigun?

Um, then Tommy can hold double miniguns. If you recall, the minigun was NEVER something you could dual-wield....

The answer is simple. Whoever is programmed to win. Because that's all they are. Programs. But not just programs, almost identical programs. They are not programmed to be better than each other, because both are to be played by you and then it's just your skill((reflexes, mainly)), and not the character's.

So it's whoever is "told" to win. And even if you have a match((whether it be programmed or controlled by players)), that isn't saying anything but who has faster reflexes((in accordance to the players)) or who is more liked by whoever programmed them.

These are retarded topics.

[Nate10]

CJ coz he is from the hood.

What the hell are you talking about! Because Carl is from the hood O.o? Most gangsters are horrible shooters!!!

Spaz is right....

[tilly]

CJ because he can hold guns. double minigun?

Um, then Tommy can hold double miniguns. If you recall, the minigun was NEVER something you could dual-wield....

The answer is simple. Whoever is programmed to win. Because that's all they are. Programs. But not just programs, almost identical programs. They are not programmed to be better than each other, because both are to be played by you and then it's just your skill((reflexes, mainly)), and not the character's.

So it's whoever is "told" to win. And even if you have a match((whether it be programmed or controlled by players)), that isn't saying anything but who has faster reflexes((in accordance to the players)) or who is more liked by whoever programmed them.

These are retarded topics.

HEY! weapons file, change minigun to one handed dual wieldable.

[Rashon.]

Yeah, this protagonist vs. protagonist topics are getting old and dumb. I don't even have an answer for this.

[deathfun]

You may be right, but there is a truth in the fact that there may be nothing better to do.

[Urbanoutlaw]

In the fantasy context this topic was probably meant to be in, Tommy.

I like CJ, but Tommy is more aggressive. When things got rough (before the game starts) CJ got out of town, & you never

quite hear the end of it.

Tommy got the rep of being the "Harwood Butcher" & was just being released from prison for his killing spree. Sonny knew

he had to get Tommy away from Liberty or it would just happen again. Besides, Tommy is a complete psycho.

[deathfun]

He was set up, remember?

[Marty Jay]

i would say Tommy would win,

1. cj holds his pistols sideways, (i have tried doing that with my air pistol and its much harder to hit the target)

2. tommy is just a maniac who could probably kill cj by pointing his fingers at him and then saying, "BANG"

[Angry Gorilla]

Shouldn't this be in the Fun & Games topic, this subforum is for discussion of GTA; San Andreas after all.

But anyway I think both of them would have killed each other when they pulled their trigger fingers at the same time, because you shoot by pressing a button.

[Connor]

It's obvious that Tommy is going to win, he's just completely mad, he wouldn't take any shit from his gang either;

Scenario one:

Sweet goes piss mad at Tommy for leaving the hood, Tommy responds by shoving a pistol in Sweet's face.

Scenario two:

A gang member says he can't recruit him because he hasn't got enough respect, Tommy's answer was, "You either come with me or get shot in the face".

Scenario three:

Tenpenny pushes Tommy to the floor, Tommy reacts by blowing Tenpenny's head off with a Sawn-Off Shotgun.

Tommy is just much more aggressive and psycho than Carl, Tommy wouldn't take that kind of bullshit, he would end up killing half of Los Santos by the end of the game.

So it's a fact that Tommy would just go up to Carl and kill him before he starts talking all his gangsta crap.

[J-Roc]

A upperhand that Cj would has is he can duel wield and tommy cant. CJ also has more guns. I vote for CJ

[JustADummy]

Neither of them, Niko Bellic shot a realistic graphics shot gun and kills twice he two

[roXas321]

Vote for CJ. I love his shooting skills